Pages

 

Irrelevant Aside On Friedman's Methodology

0 comments
You may sometimes read (neoclassical) "Economic theory shows" p. Often these claims are untrue. One can prove this falsity by constructing examples in which the assumptions of (neoclassical) economic theory hold, but not p results. So the statement you have read is logically flawed.

I sometimes encounter people who respond with the non sequitur, "Assumptions do not need to be realistic." If this response made sense, those who propound it would be able to specify which assumption is claimed to be unrealistic in these examples. Good neoclassical economists understand this logic.

Anyways, those economists that insist that assumptions do not need to be realistic - that, in fact, unrealistic assumptions are actually desirable - probably take their position from Milton Friedman. From Steve Keen's Debunking Economics, I found a response by Alan Musgrave to this idea. Musgrave, perhaps when combined with a later Uskali Mäki comment, seems to me perceptive. From these two authors, one can get a taxonomy of assumptions. Here's Musgrave's, albeit with the first reworded following Mäki's suggestion:
  • Negligibility: "The hypothesis that some factor", or combination of factors "has an effect upon" "the phenomenon under investigation" "small enough to be neglected relative to a given purpose".
  • Domain: A specification of the domain of applicability of a theory.
  • Heuristic: An assumption for developing a theory in a simple form that can be removed in later approximations.
The same wording might be used to express an assumption in all categories. For example, a model assumption might be "The government has a balanced budget". This might mean that the effects of budget imbalances have a negligible effect on the results of the model, that the model only applies when the budget is balanced, or that the model can be developed in a more complicated fashion with no assumption on the balance of the budget. Pace Friedman, assumptions, properly paraphrased, better be true ("realistic") in applications.

Update: Radek doubts some economists write "Economic theory shows..." As far as I am concerned, this is close enough:
"These observations should not be puzzling, for they are what standard economic theory predicts." -- Edward C. Prescott (1986). "Theory Ahead of Business Cycle Measurement", Quarterly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis (Fall): 9-22
References
  • Milton Friedman (1953). "The Methodology of Positive Economics", in Essays in Positive Economics, University of Chicago Press
  • Uskali Mäki (2000). "Kinds of Assumptions and Their Truth: Shaking an Untwisted F-Twist", Kyklos, V. 53, Fasc. 3: 317-336
  • Alan Musgrave (1981). "'Unreal Assumptions' in Economic Theory: The F-Twist Untwisted", Kyklos, V. 34, Fasc 3: 377-387

0 comments:

Post a Comment

  • Greenspan's Cult of Personality... Review topics and articles of economics: Alan Greenspan was a legend in his time and there was no shortage of praise for him back then. For example, who can forget Bob Woodow's 2000 book Maestro: Greenspan's...
  • Yes Tyler, Low Interest Rates Matte... Tyler Cowen is wondering whether the Fed's low interest rates in the early-to-mid 2000s really were that important to the credit and housing boom of the early-to-mid...
  • The Eurozone Crisis: Deja Vu... Review topics and articles of economics: Randal Forsyth sees similarities between the current unfolding of the Eurozone crisis and that of the U.S. financial crisis a few years back:Just as the problem on this...
  • Charles Plosser and the Burden of F... The Economist's Free Exchange blog is shocked to hear this from Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia President Charles Plosser:"Since expectations play an important role...
  • Arnold Kling and Expected Inflation... Review topics and articles of economics: What do we know about expected inflation? According to Arnold Kling not much if we look to financial markets:I'm also not convinced that we can read expected inflation...
  • A Paper on Stabilizing Nominal Spen... Given the recent discussion on stabilizing nominal spending as a policy goal I found this article by Evan F. Koenig of the Dallas Fed to be interesting: The article...
  • Why The Low Interest Rates Mattered... Review topics and articles of economics: This is the second of two posts detailing why the Fed's low interest rate policies in the early-to-mid 2000s was one of the more important contributors to the credit and...
  • Why The Low Interest Rates Mattered... This is the first of a two-part follow up to my previous post, where I argued that the Fed's low interest rate policy was a key contributor to the credit and housing...
  • The Stance of Monetary Policy Via t... Review topics and articles of economics: There has been some interesting conversations on the stance of monetary policy in the past few days between Arnold Kling, Scott Sumner, and Josh Hendrickson. Part of...
  • Scott Sumner's New Best Friend:... Joseph Gagnon is calling for $6 trillion more in global monetary easing. This should not be too hard to implement since the Fed is a monetary superpower.Update: The...
 
Review topics and articles of economics © 2011 Irrelevant Aside On Friedman's Methodology